What's the median home price in Middletown, KY?

The most recent city-level figure is $347,500, up 9.4% year-over-year (Redfin, November 2025). The broader 40243 ZIP — which blends in Douglass Hills condos — runs closer to $330K.

How fast do homes sell in Middletown?

Homes averaged 45 days on market, down from a 56-day pace a year earlier, with 14 sales that month versus 7 the year before.

What makes Middletown different from Prospect or Lake Forest?

Same eastern Jefferson County access and schools at roughly half the median price. You trade estate lots and golf-course amenities for a walkable historic square and established executive subdivisions.

Homes for Sale in Middletown, KY

Middletown blends a walkable historic square with newer executive subdivisions like Poplar Woods and the Douglass Hills border — a favorite for buyers who want East End schools and easy access to the Gene Snyder without the Prospect/Lake Forest price tag. See every active Middletown listing on the full MLS portal, then call or text me for the ones worth seeing in person.

Jefferson County · ZIP 40243

Middletown Market Snapshot

Source: Redfin, November 2025 (city of Middletown)

Median Sale Price

$347,500

Up 9.4% year-over-year

Days on Market

Faster than the 56-day pace a year ago

Homes Sold

In November 2025, up from 7 last year

City

Beds

Baths

Min price

Max price

Active Middletown listings

Live MLS results for Middletown open in the full listing portal with photos, maps and saved favorites.

See Middletown homes

Middletown real estate questions

Want Middletown listings sent to you first?

Tell me your price range and must-haves and I'll email new Middletown matches before they hit the public sites.